Most leaders think of storytelling as something they do occasionally.
A town hall.
A presentation.
A strategy deck.
But in reality, leaders are storytelling all the time - even when they say very little.
Every decision.
Every reaction.
Every silence.
They all tell a story.
The story leaders don’t realize they’re telling
Consider a few everyday moments:
A leader asks for bold ideas… and then questions every assumption.
A manager says “this is important,” but never allocates time or budget.
A team raises a concern, and it’s acknowledged—but never revisited.
Nothing explicit is said.
Yet a very clear story is told:
Ideas are welcome, but only safe ones.
This matters in theory, not in practice.
Speaking up doesn’t really change outcomes.
These stories shape behavior far more powerfully than vision statements or strategy documents.
Why words matter less than patterns
What people believe in organizations is rarely based on what leaders say.
It’s based on what they observe repeatedly.
Patterns become narratives:
What gets rewarded
What gets ignored
What gets escalated
What quietly dies
Over time, people stop listening to announcements and start reading signals.
And those signals form the organization’s real story.
Storytelling is not communication. It’s alignment.
This is where many leaders misunderstand storytelling.
Storytelling is not:
Adding emotion to slides
Making presentations more engaging
Being a better speaker
At its core, storytelling is about alignment between intent and experience.
When what you say aligns with what people see, trust builds.
When it doesn’t, cynicism quietly grows.
No amount of articulation can fix that gap.
The invisible narrator: leader behavior
Every leader is an invisible narrator in their organization.
Through:
How decisions are made
How uncertainty is handled
How failure is treated
How trade-offs are explained (or avoided)
The question isn’t whether leaders are storytelling.
It’s whether they are conscious of the story being told.
A quiet reflection
If your team had to describe the story your leadership tells - without using your words - what would they say?
Not what you intend to communicate.
But what your actions consistently signal.
That story is already shaping culture, motivation, and decision-making.
Whether you planned it or not.
And that’s a wrap for today. More soon!
Best,
Piyush
Next: Why teams respond to stories more than instructions
Thank you for reading. See you in the next edition!
I'd love you to join me on this journey! I regularly share my thoughts on how to stay ahead with timeless strategies and fresh insights for leaders. I cut through the noise and get straight to the knowledge that matters in just 2 mins.
📧Click here to subscribe.
